System Justification Leads to Ignoring COVID-19 Safety Precautions

COVID-19 has been a force in our lives for the last 10 months.

At this point, we know the standard procedures for safety precautions, like wearing a mask, keeping physical distance, and avoiding crowded public spaces.

We’ve even started administering a vaccine to healthcare workers and the elderly, with the FDA emergency-use authorization of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine this past weekend.

But despite all this, the pandemic still isn’t over.

COVID-19 cases are spiking in many areas across the country as people move events indoors due to colder weather and are travelling more for the holidays. Not to mention pandemic fatigue.

Another big safety concern is using “system justification” to ignore safety precautions.

This happens when people rationalize unsafe behaviors (like refusing to wear a mask and gathering in public spaces indoors) because it better fits their worldview and beliefs. They mistakenly think that the virus isn’t a serious problem, so they won’t take the necessary steps to address it.

Unfortunately, engaging in unsafe behaviors and ignoring safety precautions will lead to an uptick in COVID-19 cases, which disproportionately harms Latinos.

We must learn what system justification is and seek to avoid it so that we can keep the virus at bay until a COVID-19 vaccine is available for everyone.

What is System Justification?

System justification is a social psychology theory that states people will rationalize whatever the status quo is. They believe the social, economic, and political systems must be fair and advantageous, otherwise they would not be in place.

“System justification is a ‘potentially strong motivator of human behavior because it addresses fundamental human needs to reduce uncertainty, threat, and social discord,’ and can make people feel better, happier and more satisfied with the status quo on an emotional level,” according to a Salud America! research review.

But unfortunately, it can also stop progress from happening in social justice movements.

We see many socio-economic examples of this, such as with the income and wealth gap and racial/ethnic disparities in health, education, and more.

“‘System justification’ theorists like psychologist John Jost have shown how situations that represent a perceived threat to established systems trigger inflexible thinking,” reports Adrian Bardon in Scientific American.

This is particularly devastating when it comes to COVID-19.

Pandemic Fatigue

“There is a marked gap in expressed concern over the coronavirus depending on political party affiliation, apparently based in part on partisan disagreements over factual issues like the effectiveness of social distancing or the actual COVID-19 death rate,” Barden wrote.

When people base their opinions on COVID-19 through identity and politics rather than science, it will lead to disagreements on how to best reduce the spread of the virus.

How is System Justification Linked to Identity?

System justification is tied to identity because it takes more than just presenting someone with the facts to change their worldview.

“In theory, resolving factual disputes should be relatively easy: Just present strong evidence, or evidence of a strong expert consensus. But things don’t work that way when scientific advice presents a picture that threatens someone’s perceived interests or ideological worldview. In practice, it turns out that one’s political, religious or ethnic identity quite effectively predicts one’s willingness to accept expertise on any given politicized issue,” wrote Bardon, according to Scientific American.

In fact, it can be impossible to separate our responses and beliefs from our identity.

“Human cognition is inseparable from the unconscious emotional responses that go with it. Under the right conditions, universal human traits like in-group favoritism, existential anxiety and a desire for stability and control combine into a toxic, system-justifying identity politics,” Bardon wrote.

Examples of System Justification in the COVID-19 Pandemic

There are several ways that people might express beliefs that don’t follow scientific guidelines because they better fit their beliefs.

Here are some examples of what someone might say:

  • The current safety measures in my city must be enough, so I don’t have to practice being safe myself.
  • Nobody I know has gotten sick, so I don’t even think the virus is real. I don’t need to wear a mask.
  • The COVID-19 spike has to get worse before it gets better, so there’s nothing we can do.
  • It’s that person’s fault if they got COVID-19, because our city is doing the best it can to fight it.
  • My city hasn’t banned crowded public gatherings, so it must be safe, otherwise they would tell me it isn’t.

Who Does System Justification Harm?

System justification can be dangerous if it leads to a higher spread of COVID-19.

Engaging in unsafe behaviors results in the harm of Latino communities and other communities of color that have been disproportionately affected by COVID-19.

Not only are Latinos 3 times as likely as white people to be diagnosed with COVID-19, but they also comprise 43.2% of COVID-19-related deaths among the 0-24 age range, according to data from the CDC.

COVID-19 ‘Long Haulers’ Latinos Long-Term Risk

Latinos also have higher rates of diabetes and cancer compared to the overall U.S. population, meaning that they are likely to have pre-existing conditions that make the impact of COVID-19 much more serious than other groups.

 

This means that if you refuse to take safety precautions, it could mean life or death for others.

That’s why we must stay vigilant against COVID-19.

How to Avoid System Justification

System justification is difficult to address, because it involves confronting how people’s beliefs are tightly bound to their identities.

The main way we can tackle system justification is through effective communication.

“Effective communication allows individuals to voice their points of view without attacking another’s views, and without feeling attacked,” according to a Salud America! research review.

If you have an opportunity to openly address someone’s unsafe behavior regarding COVID-19 precautions, you should do so in a way that allows them to openly speak without fear of being reprimanded.

Effective communication must also come from trusted health authorities.

“Effective science communication is critically important because of the profound effects partisan messaging can have on public attitudes,” wrote Bardon, according to Scientific American.

If you can connect with people and present them unbiased, factual scientific information in a way that doesn’t make them feel attacked, it will work best.

If you need a resource for the important facts and information about COVID-19, check out our “Juntos, We Can Stop COVID-19” digital communication campaign.

Salud America! at UT Health San Antonio launched “Juntos, We Can Stop COVID-19” to help Latino families and workers take action to slow the spread of coronavirus.

The #JuntosStopCovid campaign features bilingual, culturally relevant fact sheets, infographics, and video role model stories to encourage Latinos to change their public health behaviors.

Share the campaign with your friends, family, and colleagues!

SHARE THE CAMPAIGN!

The post System Justification Leads to Ignoring COVID-19 Safety Precautions appeared first on Salud America.

Related Articles

Mechanism of Discrimination: The Problem of System Justification

This is part of the Salud America! Achieving a Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities: A Research Review» System Justification Is a Key Mechanism People Use to Excuse Discrimination among People of Color, Those in Poverty System justification is the label for a social psychology theory asserting that people will rationalize …
The post Mechanism of Discrimination: The Problem of System Justification appeared first on Salud America.

Achieving a Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities: A Research Review

Do you notice how much some of your neighbors are suffering? A widening socioeconomic gap, racism, and discrimination contribute to inequitable distribution of healthcare and mental and physical health disparities among Latinos and other people of color and those in poverty, especially amid COVID-19. But it doesn’t have to be this way. A cohesive culture …
The post Achieving a Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities: A Research Review appeared first on Salud America.

4 Reasons to Think Structuralist, Instead of Individualistic, to Improve Health Equity

Every person is a unique individual. But if you look closely, you’ll see each person lives, learns, works, and plays within social and environmental conditions that influence their individual health and wealth. Some people face health barriers because of structural and systemic policies that curb their access to quality housing, transportation, medical care, food, jobs, …
The post 4 Reasons to Think Structuralist, Instead of Individualistic, to Improve Health Equity appeared first on Salud America.

How a Smoke-Free Policy Protects Apartment Tenants from Secondhand Smoke, COVID-19

Does someone smoke in your apartment complex? You might be inhaling your neighbor’s secondhand smoke. Inside multifamily dwellings, secondhand smoke can travel through doorways, halls, windows, ventilation systems, electrical outlets, and gaps around fixtures and pipes. Secondhand smoke, already a cancer-causing killer of millions, also might contribute to the spread of coronavirus. While there is …
The post How a Smoke-Free Policy Protects Apartment Tenants from Secondhand Smoke, COVID-19 appeared first on Salud America.

Introduction & Methods: A Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities

This is part of the Salud America! Achieving a Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities: A Research Review» Abstract Health inequities are persistent in the United States. A widening socioeconomic gap, extensive poverty, and multi-level racism, discrimination, and segregation contribute to inequitable distribution of healthcare, resources, and a significant disparity in …
The post Introduction & Methods: A Cohesive Culture for Health Equity in Latino and All Communities appeared first on Salud America.

Responses

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *